My husband’s mistress thought she’d steal him from me and take my house too.

The Lemon Socks and the Scripted Lie

My husband’s mistress thought she’d steal him from me and take my house too until I revealed something that shocked her. The day I caught my husband cheating I was wearing compression socks with tiny lemons on them because that’s what passes for personality when you live in scrubs.

I had just walked out of a meeting at the hospital where a doctor talked to me like I personally invented staffing shortages. I was sitting in my car in the employee lot trying to remember what it felt like to breathe without a timer.

My phone rang and it was my best friend and the way she said my name made my stomach drop before she even said anything else.

“Are you at that restaurant off the highway?” she asked.

I blinked at the steering wheel.

“No why would I be there?” I asked.

“I just saw your husband,” she said and then rushed the rest out like she wanted it to land softly.

“I thought you were with him.” she added.

My hands went cold. I did that stupid thing people do when something bad happens and you try to turn it into a joke so it doesn’t become real.

“He told me he’s still at the office,” I said laughing once dry and wrong.

There was a pause the kind that feels like a door closing. I called him right there. He picked up on the third ring too quick like he’d been waiting for the screen to light up.

“Hey babe,” he said bright and breathy.

“Where are you?” I asked.

I tried to sound normal like I wasn’t about to swallow my own pulse.

“At work,” he said instantly.

“Late meeting it’s a mess I’ll be home late.” he said.

He said it like he was reading from a script and the thing is he was good at scripts. He was a sales manager at a distribution company his entire job was convincing people that the story he was telling was the truth and for 2 years of marriage I’d been one of his easiest customers.

“Okay,” I said because my mouth was still pretending my life was normal.

Then I hung up and just stared at the dashboard until my vision went a little fuzzy. My name is Blythe. Yes that’s my real name and no it has never made my life soft or delicate like people assume.

I’m in my early 30s and I work as a nursing coordinator at a regional hospital in the United States which is a fancy way of saying I spend my days putting out fires with a clipboard. I do schedules I handle complaints I play therapist to burnout nurses and punching bag to stressed out families and I keep telling myself it matters because it does.

It also drains you in a way that makes your bones feel tired. Two years ago when I married my husband we started out in a rental like most people do. It was fine in that bland way rentals are fine when you’re trying to pretend you’re stable.

Then about 18 months ago my grandmother passed and left me her house and we moved into it. I remember standing in the kitchen with the papers in my hand and thinking “This is mine not ours not someday not maybe mine.”.

The house wasn’t huge but it was solid it was the kind of place with a creaky hallway and a backyard you have to mow even when you’re depressed because neighbors love judging grass. It had a little porch where my grandmother used to sit with her coffee and watch the street like it was a reality show.

It was valued somewhere around $380,000 which sounds like a fortune until you remember it’s a normal house in the United States and housing prices are a joke nobody’s laughing at. And no before anyone asks it wasn’t magically free just because it was inherited.

The house wasn’t fully paid off when it came to me there was still a remaining balance and ongoing costs so the word mortgage was technically true even if it didn’t feel like mine emotionally yet. Between taxes insurance repairs and that leftover balance it was still the kind of blessing that comes with a monthly reminder attached.

My husband loved that house. I told myself he loved it because it was our home. Looking back I can admit the other truth without choking on it he loved what it represented security status a shortcut and the worst part I ignored the tiny warning signs because I wanted a calm life so badly.

I wanted to be the woman who didn’t have drama. I wanted to be the woman who had a husband and a house and a job and could just go to work come home eat dinner and watch some mindless show until she fell asleep.

Instead I ended up driving 40 minutes to a restaurant I didn’t even like. I didn’t go in right away. I parked took a breath and told myself my best friend could be wrong.

Maybe he was there with a client maybe it was some coworker who looked like him maybe the universe wasn’t about to drop kick my life. Then I saw him through the window.

He was leaning in close to a woman with glossy hair and a laugh that carried through the glass. Her hand was on his forearm like she had a right to be there. He looked relaxed in a way I hadn’t seen in months like his body knew he was exactly where he wanted it to be.

And I recognized her immediately because she’s been a shadow on my life since childhood. I call her the woman because I refuse to give her the dignity of a name in my story.

She was a known quantity at every family event because her parents have been close friends with mine for decades the kind of friendships my mother treats like a blood oath. Growing up the woman was always around always smiling too sweetly always making little comments that looked innocent if you didn’t know her.

She wasn’t the type who shoved you into lockers she was the type who laughed when someone else did then asked you later if you were okay in that fake concern voice that makes you feel smaller. When I was younger she copied me in the most annoying ways.

If I got bangs she got bangs if I started wearing a certain color she did too but better. If I got praised for a grade she’d ask loudly if I cheated and then giggle like it was a joke.

As adults she got slicker. She’d compliment my job in this syrupy tone like she was praising a child for tying their shoes. She’d ask what I made what my schedule was whether my husband helped me and she’d do it all with that soft smile that makes you sound paranoid if you call it out.

So when I saw her hand on my husband’s arm it didn’t even feel like a surprise. It felt like the last piece sliding into place like my life had been building toward this moment and I’d just been too tired to notice.

I didn’t storm in I didn’t throw a drink I didn’t make a scene. I sat there frozen feeling like I’d been sedated. My body went heavy my thoughts slowed down.

I lifted my phone hands trembling and took a photo through the window. It wasn’t cinematic it was proof the kind of proof you take when you already know people are going to ask “Are you sure?”.

Then still sitting in my car I opened my phone and created a new email account a secret one right there in the parking lot like a paranoid teenager hiding a diary. I can hear myself now.

Hi yes I’m a married woman with a full-time job and a joint account and I’m making burner emails in a parking lot. I sent the photo to myself because I suddenly trusted nothing not my phone not my memory not my ability to stay calm.

I drove home on autopilot. I took a shower that didn’t wash anything off. I ate cereal for dinner because the idea of real food made me gag.

When my husband called later and said he’d be working late the audacity made my jaw ache from clenching.

“Okay,” I said like I was polite to my own destruction.

That night he still came home eventually showered slid into bed and breathed beside me like nothing happened. I stared at the ceiling and counted his breaths like a metronome because focusing on anything else made me feel like I might start screaming and never stop.

The next morning I texted a coworker of his someone I’d met once at a holiday party and barely knew. I kept it casual because I still had this embarrassing shred of hope that maybe there was a normal explanation.